What Can Cause an Unstable Product Roadmap: Reasons + Examples

If you're a product manager, you know that creating a product roadmap is a crucial part of the development process.

A product roadmap is a strategic document that outlines the vision, direction, and goals for a product over a specific period. It's a living document that helps align the team and stakeholders around the product vision, communicate the product's progress, and make important decisions about the product's future.

However, a product roadmap can become unstable if it's not managed correctly.

An unstable product roadmap can lead to missed deadlines, wasted resources, and a lack of direction for the product.

There are several reasons why a product roadmap can become unstable. One of the main reasons is a lack of clarity around the product vision. If the product vision is not clearly defined, it's challenging to create a roadmap that aligns with the vision. Additionally, if the product vision changes frequently, it can lead to an unstable roadmap that doesn't reflect the current priorities.

In this blog post, I will be explaining you what are the essential components of a product roadmap, what are the main factors that can cause a roadmap to fail and some real life examples of failed products

Essential Components of a Product Roadmap

A stable product roadmap should have the following essential components:

• Product Vision: A clear and concise product vision is essential for a stable product roadmap. It should define the product's purpose, target audience, and value proposition. The product vision should be aligned with the company's overall vision and mission statement.
• Product Strategy: A well-defined product strategy should be based on market research, customer feedback, and industry trends. It should outline the product's unique selling points, competitive advantage, and positioning in the market.
• Goals and Objectives: The product roadmap should have clear and measurable goals and objectives. These goals should be aligned with the product strategy and should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART).
• Prioritization: Prioritization is critical for a stable product roadmap. The product development team should prioritize features and enhancements based on their impact on the product vision, customer needs, and business goals.
• Timeline: The product roadmap should have a realistic timeline that outlines the planned releases, milestones, and deadlines. The timeline should be flexible enough to accommodate changes and adjustments based on feedback and market conditions.

What Can Cause an Unstable Product Roadmap?

A product roadmap can become unstable if not managed correctly, leading to missed deadlines, wasted resources, and a lack of direction for the product.

Here are six common pitfalls of making a product roadmap that is bound to fail:

1. The Roadmap is Just a List of Features

One of the most common reasons product roadmaps fail is that they are mistaken for mere lists of features and details to be included in the product.

A product roadmap should be a strategic tool that clearly and quickly communicates a product owner’s overall strategic vision and plan for the product’s development.

It should include high-level information—themes, epics, goals, and possibly some user stories and timeframes, but not an exhaustive list of features. A feature list can lead to several problems:

• Loss of Focus: A long list of items can cause stakeholders to lose focus and interest.
• Lack of Value Communication: Sales and marketing teams may not know which features are most important or why, making it difficult to create compelling messages for prospects and customers.
• Developer Confusion: Developers may not understand which items are priority or how they tie together to create value for the user.

2. The Roadmap is a Static Document

A static product roadmap, built using word processors, spreadsheets, or presentation software, is also prone to failure. A product roadmap is a living document that needs to be regularly updated to reflect changes in priorities, resources, budgets, and external pressures. If the roadmap is static, it will quickly become outdated, leading to several issues:

• Outdated Information: Key players across the product’s cross-functional teams may unknowingly review and follow an outdated roadmap.
• Version Control Problems: Multiple versions of the roadmap can exist, leading to confusion about which version is up-to-date and accurate.

3. The Roadmap is Too Detailed

While detailed plans are necessary for the product development process, the product roadmap itself should remain high-level. Its primary job is to capture and communicate the product's strategic vision. Including too many details can result in:

• Loss of Big-Picture Strategy: Teams may lose sight of the strategic vision buried under a mountain of details.
• Failure to Generate Momentum: A detailed roadmap can fail to build enthusiasm and support for the product if the reasoning behind it is obscured.

4. The Roadmap’s Themes and Epics Don’t Deliver the Right Value

Even if a product roadmap is strategically designed and visually clear, it can still fail if it does not solve the right problems for customers. This can occur due to a lack of industry research, poor data analysis, or insufficient customer interaction. Consequences include:

• Failure to Meet Customer Needs: The product will ultimately come up short with customers if it doesn't address their needs.
• Loss of Credibility: Failing to meet customer expectations can damage the company’s reputation, making customers less likely to engage with future products.

5. The Roadmap is Unrealistic

Unrealistic expectations can be built into a product roadmap due to pressure from executives, investors, or customers. This can involve promising sophisticated functionality that the development team cannot deliver or setting impossible deadlines. The impact of an unrealistic roadmap includes:

• Damage to Development Team Relationships: Developers are set up for failure, harming team morale and future projects.
• Disappointment and Frustration: Failing to meet unrealistic promises can leave stakeholders, customers, and other key groups upset.

6. Misalignment with Stakeholders

Misalignment with stakeholders is another critical factor leading to an unstable product roadmap. This can happen when stakeholders are not involved in the roadmap creation process or when their feedback is not considered. This can lead to:

• Confusion and Disagreement: The roadmap may not reflect the priorities and needs of the stakeholders, causing conflicts and misunderstandings.
• Lack of Direction: Misalignment can lead to an unclear direction for the product, resulting in wasted resources and missed opportunities.

7. Inadequate Resource Allocation

Another factor that can lead to an unstable roadmap is inadequate resource allocation. This can happen when the roadmap is created without considering the resources required to achieve the goals outlined in the roadmap. As a result, the team may not have the necessary resources to complete the tasks on time or at the desired level of quality, leading to delays and frustration. To avoid this, it is important to allocate resources based on the goals outlined in the roadmap and to regularly review the resource allocation to ensure it is still appropriate.

8. Shifting Priorities and Deadlines

Finally, shifting priorities and deadlines can also lead to an unstable roadmap. This can happen when the goals and priorities of the project change, or when deadlines are not realistic or are constantly changing. As a result, the roadmap may become outdated or irrelevant, leading to confusion and frustration. To avoid this, it is important to regularly review and update the roadmap to reflect any changes in priorities or deadlines.

Real-Life Examples of Product Roadmaps That Failed

1. Google Glass

Google Glass was a highly anticipated product, expected to revolutionize wearable technology. However, the product roadmap for Google Glass failed in several critical areas, leading to its eventual downfall.

Key Issues:

• Overpromising and Under-delivering: Google hyped the capabilities of Google Glass, creating unrealistic expectations. The final product fell short of the promised features and usability.
• Privacy Concerns: Google failed to address privacy issues effectively, leading to public backlash. People were uncomfortable with the idea of being recorded without their consent.
• Market Readiness: The roadmap did not adequately assess market readiness. The product was ahead of its time, and the market was not prepared to adopt such technology.

Source: Forbes

2. Microsoft Zune

Microsoft Zune was launched as a competitor to Apple's iPod. Despite significant investment and a clear roadmap, Zune failed to gain traction in the market.

Key Issues:

• Late Entry: Microsoft entered the market too late. By the time Zune was released, Apple had already established a dominant position with the iPod.
• Lack of Unique Value Proposition: The roadmap focused on copying the iPod rather than offering unique features that would differentiate Zune in the market.
• Marketing Failures: The marketing strategy outlined in the roadmap did not resonate with consumers, leading to poor sales.

3. Segway

The Segway was touted as a groundbreaking personal transportation device. However, the product roadmap failed to foresee several critical issues, leading to its underwhelming market performance.

Key Issues:

• Overhyped Expectations: The Segway was marketed as a revolutionary product that would change urban transportation. The hype did not match the reality, leading to disappointment.
• Regulatory Hurdles: The roadmap did not adequately address regulatory issues. Many cities restricted or banned Segway usage on sidewalks and streets.
• High Cost: The high price point was a significant barrier to adoption, which was not anticipated in the roadmap.

4. Amazon Fire Phone

Amazon's Fire Phone was expected to be a major player in the smartphone market. However, it turned out to be a costly failure.

Key Issues:

• Lack of Unique Features: The roadmap failed to identify a compelling unique selling point. The Fire Phone's standout feature, Dynamic Perspective, was not enough to attract consumers.
• High Price: Priced similarly to high-end smartphones, the Fire Phone did not offer enough value to justify its cost.
• Limited App Ecosystem: The roadmap did not address the need for a robust app ecosystem, leading to limited app availability compared to competitors.

5. Quibi

Quibi, a short-form video streaming service, launched with a lot of fanfare but failed within six months.

Key Issues:

• Misreading the Market: The roadmap did not align with market needs. Quibi bet on people watching short videos on the go, but the COVID-19 pandemic kept people at home, where they preferred longer content.
• Content Strategy: The roadmap focused on star-studded content but failed to deliver engaging and compelling stories that resonated with viewers.
• Pricing Model: Quibi's pricing model was not competitive with other streaming services, leading to poor subscriber numbers.

These real-life examples illustrate how critical it is to have a well-thought-out, flexible, and realistic product roadmap. Missteps in market assessment, overpromising, inadequate differentiation, and failing to adapt to changing circumstances can all lead to a product's downfall.

Maintaining and Communicating the Roadmap

Once you have developed a product roadmap, it is essential to maintain it as a living document. This means that you need to update it regularly to reflect changes in the market, customer needs, and internal priorities.

Keeping the roadmap up to date ensures that everyone in the organization has a shared understanding of the product development process and can make informed decisions about resource allocation and priorities.

Effective Use of Tools and Techniques for Product Managers

One of the most effective ways to maintain a product roadmap is to use the right tools and techniques. There are many project management and collaboration tools available that can help you keep the roadmap up to date and ensure that everyone in the organization has access to the latest information. Some of these tools include ProductLogz, ProductPlan, ProductBoard, Jira that can help you startegize your roadmap in a realistic way.

Another effective technique is to use a visual roadmap that clearly communicates the product development process and highlights key milestones and deliverables. A visual roadmap can help you communicate the roadmap to stakeholders and ensure that everyone understands the product development process.

Fostering Cross-Functional Collaboration

Maintaining a product roadmap also requires cross-functional collaboration. This means that everyone in the organization needs to work together to ensure that the roadmap is up to date and reflects the latest priorities and customer needs.

To foster cross-functional collaboration, it is essential to communicate regularly with all stakeholders. This includes product managers, engineers, designers, sales teams, and customer service teams. Regular communication ensures that everyone is aligned around the product development process and understands their role in delivering the roadmap.

In addition, it is important to encourage collaboration and teamwork across functional areas. This can be achieved through regular team meetings, cross-functional training, and shared goals and objectives. By fostering a collaborative culture, you can ensure that everyone is working together to deliver the best possible product roadmap.

Conclusion

An unstable product roadmap can cause significant disruptions in product development, leading to wasted resources, missed deadlines, and ultimately, product failure. To ensure stability, it is essential to treat the roadmap as a strategic, living document that aligns with the product vision and strategy. Regularly updating the roadmap, involving stakeholders, and maintaining a high-level strategic focus are crucial steps to avoid the common pitfalls that lead to instability. By addressing these factors, product managers can create and maintain effective roadmaps that guide successful product development.

‍